View Full Version : new discovery's --MODS
DRG
June 14th, 2020, 01:07 PM
I've been interested in WW2 era history and equipment, particularly aircraft, armoured vehicles and weapons for well over 5 decades so when I discover something totally new it's a surprise.
Up until two days ago, I had not known about the Kharkiv R-10 ( sometimes known as the Kharkiv KhAI-5 and sometimes as the Neman R-10). Usually, if something like this happens it's because they were produced on a very limited basis but there were around 500 R-10's built and that is not a trifling number. Their first combat use was at Khalkhin Go and they were used to at least the end of 1943.
They are in the game now as fighter bombers and recce aircraft and in game terms for 1939 are the most modern UC 44 aircraft in the Russian OOB.
Just saying because this long after WW2 it's remarkable to find something "new"
https://i.imgur.com/nAvz4N9.png
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-iNV3fCQ6OSQ/Vsgm_n_X2BI/AAAAAAAAVaQ/hXI1P4sgnMo/s1600/nieman%2B4.jpg
Karagin
June 14th, 2020, 09:06 PM
Very cool. A lot interesting things were built, tried, and forgotten before and during World War 2.
DRG
June 14th, 2020, 10:43 PM
And this.... a Grigorovich IP-1 only 90 made and only used for 4 years but 90 is a respectable number and was used from 1936-1940
https://i.imgur.com/OG6dEdh.png
When looked at from top down it has many similarities to the Mitsubishi A5M including wingspan.
I like building aircraft......it's why there are too many in the game
Karagin
June 15th, 2020, 11:30 AM
We are going to need more unit slots at this rate. :D
DRG
June 15th, 2020, 12:53 PM
We are going to need more unit slots at this rate. :D
Nope. There are plenty of slots available in all OOB's but one ( German )and increased unit slots is NEVER ( never, never.... ) going to happen and neither is hiving the SS units into their own OOB.. "not gonna happen".
Increasing the number of slots at this stage would break more things than I could count and right now ( this IS year 22 we've been doing this )... we have no enthusiasm left to even try to consider a way to make it work because we bounced all the options around a decade ago and it all came back "not gonna happen". The work involved is way more than the benefits
Right now there is some German overflow in the Blue OOB and anyone who is curious or wants those units can access them as captured.
As for more new aircraft... those last two may very well be the last two but who knows I was surprised to find them I might be surprised again but I cannot really see that happening.
I have already added 100 mostly upgraded revisions to Icons in WW2 but some are new.
====================
(456,140): 263 British Beaufighter 22 263 REVISED winSPWW2 v11+REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(457,140): 264 British Blenheim 23 264 REVISED winSPWW2 v11+REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(459,117): 266 FINN Blenheim 25 266 REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(512,75): 427 Sukhoi Su-2 36 427 *****REVISED WinSPWW2 v14
(524,71): 357 LaGG.1-3 6 357 ******REV WinSPWW2 v14
(526,73): 359 A-36 Apache 8 359 ******REV WinSPWW2 v14
(527,68): 360 Yak-9 9 360 ******REV WinSPWW2 v14
(528,70): 361 La-5FN 10 361 ******REV WinSPWW2 v14
(556,108): 419 Beaufighter ( PTO ) 38 419 *******Revised WinSPWW2V12******REV WinSPWW2 v14
(595,124): 480 Letov S 328 (Czech) 2 480 ***** REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(599,123): 484 JU-86 ( Hungarian ) 6 484 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(613,114): 498 Commonwealth CA-1 Wirraway ( ANZAC) 20 498 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(615,110): 500 Commonwealth CA-12 Boomerang ( ANZAC) 22 500 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(616,124): 501 Fokker D.XXI ( Finn ) 23 501 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(617,124): 502 Fokker D.XXI (Dutch ) 24 502 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(619,124): 504 Breda Ba.27 ( China ) 26 504 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(622,124): 507 Bloch MB 152 ( France ) 29 507 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(623,122): 508 Bloch MB 152 ( Romania ) 30 508 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(626,124): 511 Martin B10 USA 33 511 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(627,124): 512 Martin B10 DUTCH 34 512 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(628,124): 513 Martin B10 China 35 513 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(629,129): 920 ROM-Blenheim1 36 920 NEW-V5 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(655,130): 946 NSP-Capronchino-310 62 946 NEW-V5 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(656,130): 947 NSP-Caproni-Ca-133 63 947 NEW-V5 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(657,130): 948 NSP-Caproni-Ca-135 64 948 NEW-V5 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(714,123): 533 JU-86 ( SWEDE ) 19 533 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(718,135): 537 CR.42 Falco SWEDE 23 537 *******REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(737,131): 864 NTH-Fokker DXXI-pre war 42 864 NEW-V5 ***** REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(739,128): 866 NTH-Fokker T.V bomber [T.5] 44 866 NEW-V5 ***** REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(740,124): 867 NTH-Fokker T.V bomber [T.5]-prewar 45 867 NEW-V5 ***** REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(753,168): 880 GRK-Blenheim_MkIV 58 880 NEW-V5 ****** REVISED winSPWW2 v11*****REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(754,130): 881 GRK-Bloch_MB_152 59 881 NEW-V5 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(777,81): 904 Yugo-109 82 904 NEW-V5 *****REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(778,132): 905 Yugo-Blenheim1 83 905 NEW-V5 *****REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(780,132): 907 Yugo-caproni310 85 907 NEW-V5 *****REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(891,130): 633 SLOVAK Letov 4 633 NEW-V4 **** Revised winSPWW2 v14
(897,130): 639 CZECH LA-5 10 639 NEW-V4 **** Revised winSPWW2 v14
(915,123): 657 Caproni Ca.310 Norway 28 657 NEW-V4 * Revised winSPWW2 v14
(916,127): 658 Italian Caproni Ca.310 29 658 NEW-V4 * Revised winSPWW2 v14
(936,130): 808 Thai Martin 139W 49 808 NEW-V5 **** Revised winSPWW2 v14
(954,129): 826 BUL Letov 328 67 826 NEW-V5 **** Revised winSPWW2 v14
(955,127): 827 BUL Letov 328-44 68 827 NEW-V5 **** Revised winSPWW2 v14
(974,130): 846 CHI-Waco 240A 87 846 NEW-V5 **** REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(975,108): 847 CHI-Curtiss Hawk 68 88 847 NEW-V5 **** NEW winSPWW2 v14
(980,126): 852 PTO-Swordfish 93 852 NEW-V5 * Revised winSPWW2 v14
(983,125): 855 BRT ETO-Swordfish 96 855 NEW-V5 * Revised winSPWW2 v14
(2240,92): {9274, -1}, // 2074 Hungarian Ca 135 ** NEW WinSPWW2 v7 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(2358,102): {9388, -1}, // 2188 Spainish Republic Potez 540 ********** NEW WinSPWW2 V9***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(2359,97): {9389, -1}, // 2189 French Potez 540 camo ********** NEW WinSPWW2 V9***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(2360,98): {9390, -1}, // 2190 French Potez 540 green ********** NEW WinSPWW2 V9***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(2361,95): {9391, -1}, // 2191 Romanian Potez 543 ********** NEW WinSPWW2 V9***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(4300,85):{11186, 11187}, //4041. KV-85 Summer ******New_WinSPww2v2 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(4301,84):{11188, 11189}, //4042. KV-85 Winter ******New_WinSPww2v2 ***REVISED winSPWW2 v14
(4899,88): {12216, -1}, //4616 Potez 65T- French *******NewWinSPWW2v4 *****Revised WinSPWW2 v14
(8525,104): {18711, -1}, //8111 Free French AF Blenheim **********NEW winSPWW2 V12**********REVISED winSPWW2 V14
(8624,96): {18810, -1}, //8198 I-16 Russia_2 **********NEW winSPWW2 V12**********REVISED winSPWW2 V14
(8668,97): {18854, -1}, //8340 Hurricane RYAF **********NEW winSPWW2 V12**********REVISED winSPWW2 V14
(8735,99): {18920, -1}, //8220 IL-10 Shturmovík Green/Black ******NEW winSPWW2 V12--Corrected winSPWW2 V14
(8939,67): {19120, -1}, //8502 Sukhoi Su-2 Winter *******REV WinSPWW2 V14
(8955,72): {19136, -1}, //8518 Italian Ba-88 Lince Green *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8956,73): {19137, -1}, //8519 Italian Ba-88 Lince Desert *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8957,73): {19138, -1}, //8520 British Beaufighter Desert *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8958,68): {19139, -1}, //8521 USA Beaufighter Green *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8959,67): {19140, -1}, //8522 USA Beaufighter Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8960,69): {19141, -1}, //8523 USA Beaufighter Desert *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8961,70): {19142, -1}, //8524 Finland Blenheim Winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8962,65): {19143, -1}, //8525 PTO Blenheim Mk.I *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8963,73): {19144, -1}, //8526 British Blenheim Mk.IV Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8964,75): {19145, -1}, //8527 British Blenheim Mk.IV Desert *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8965,59): {19146, -1}, //8528 RSI Ca-310 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8966,64): {19147, -1}, //8529 Croatian Ca-311m *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8967,66): {19148, -1}, //8530 Swede Ca-313 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8968,60): {19149, -1}, //357 Yugo Me-109g *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8969,72): {19150, -1}, //8532 Soviet LAGG-1-3 green camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8970,69): {19151, -1}, //8533 Soviet LAGG-1-3 camo 2 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8971,69): {19152, -1}, //8534 Soviet LAGG-1-3 winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8972,69): {19153, -1}, //8535 Soviet La-5 Green Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8973,70): {19154, -1}, //8536 Soviet La-5 3 tone Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8974,70): {19155, -1}, //8537 Soviet La-5 winter worn *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8975,66): {19156, -1}, //8538 Soviet La-5 winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8976,67): {19157, -1}, //8539 Soviet Mig-3 Summer *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8977,67): {19158, -1}, //8540 Soviet Mig-3 Winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8978,72): {19159, -1}, //8541 Soviet Yak Green/Gray camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8979,69): {19160, -1}, //8542 Soviet Yak 3 tone Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8980,68): {19161, -1}, //8543 Soviet Yak Green Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8981,71): {19162, -1}, //8544 Soviet Yak 3 tone Camo 2 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8982,70): {19163, -1}, //8545 Soviet Yak Green Camo 2 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8983,70): {19164, -1}, //8546 Soviet Yak Green Camo 3 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8984,65): {19165, -1}, //8547 Soviet Yak Winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8985,72): {19166, -1}, //8548 Ju.86 Germany Pre war camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8986,73): {19167, -1}, //8549 Ju 86Z South Africa -Summer *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8987,78): {19168, -1}, //8550 Ju 86Z South Africa -East Africa *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8988,73): {19169, -1}, //8551 Ju.86 Germany Splinter camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8989,65): {19170, -1}, //8552 Letov S 328 Czech *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8990,68): {19171, -1}, //8553 Letov S 328 Estonian *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8991,66): {19172, -1}, //8554 Renard R31 Belgium *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8992,73): {19173, -1}, //8555 Kharkiv KhAI-5 (Neman R-10) *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8993,79): {19174, -1}, //8556 Kharkiv KhAI-5 (Neman R-10) Winter *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8994,77): {19175, -1}, //8557 Kharkiv KhAI-5 (Neman R-10) Camo *****New WinSPWW2 V14
(8995,65): {19176, -1}, //8558 Grigorovich IP-1 *****New WinSPWW2 V14
100 occurrence(s) has been found.
Pibwl
July 6th, 2020, 02:50 PM
I myself also "discovered" R-10 only ten or so years ago, when I was convinced I already knew every Soviet WW2 plane ;)
DRG
July 6th, 2020, 04:13 PM
A couple of other aircraft I have upgraded for next release........
Late-model He-111 and one version of the SM.81 along with an early Spanish 111
https://i.imgur.com/V052VJh.png
Imp
July 6th, 2020, 06:10 PM
Have to say they look really good
DRG
July 6th, 2020, 06:47 PM
Thanks. I'm quite pleased with this series
a few more
https://i.imgur.com/MGlWH0U.png
Imp
July 7th, 2020, 01:01 AM
Might need to slow the animations just to watch them fly over they are really good
DRG
July 7th, 2020, 04:36 PM
Sometimes ( it's rare ) aircraft will fly in and the game centers on the aircraft and it stays centred while the terrain under it scrolls by. Sometimes the aircraft is what scrolls which gives it a staccato-like display and I would like to find out why it sometimes comes in smoothly.
Way back the original game had a "smooth move" control that never worked well because ( I think.... ) most computers back then could not draw the graphics fast enough for it to work properly and that's another thing I want to poke around with
Karagin
July 7th, 2020, 10:51 PM
I wish I could draw as well as you guys do with the different paint programs...every time I try to do an icon for for the SHP files..yeah so much never turns out looking right.
scorpio_rocks
July 8th, 2020, 02:48 AM
I wish I could draw as well as you guys do with the different paint programs...every time I try to do an icon for for the SHP files..yeah so much never turns out looking right.
Start with small changes to an existing icon. Try just changing the colour to learn how the shading works, for instance.
Don't expect results like DRG manages, Don had been finding creative ways to get around the limitations of a restrictive palette and the pixel scale for over two decades!
Imp
July 8th, 2020, 06:12 AM
I wish I could draw as well as you guys do with the different paint programs...every time I try to do an icon for for the SHP files..yeah so much never turns out looking right.
Start with small changes to an existing icon. Try just changing the colour to learn how the shading works, for instance.
Don't expect results like DRG manages, Don had been finding creative ways to get around the limitations of a restrictive palette and the pixel scale for over two decades!
As you say its quite impressive with the scale working at sure there is quite a lot of fooling the eye by causing 'blending" to achieve a shape or shade.
DRG
July 8th, 2020, 08:30 AM
As Scorpio says, I've been doing this for 20+ years so I learned a trick or two but basically for aircraft you find a drawing then pixel reduce it to the wingspan you want.
That gives a rough starting point [A] then it gets cleaned up a bit [B] then the outline is applied over a blank fuselage with wing detail ( I have various version for single and muliti engine aircraft along with a series of engines configurations and that gets you to [C] ( more or less ) then it's adjusted a bit more [D] then the glass and prop details are added [E]
Then you create copies [F] using the various palette shades and picking the ones that give these results is part of that 20+ years experience and how many are done depends on how many you need.
Since all the copies are exact duplicates you can start with a base [G] then cut out one of the copies [H] then paste it to the base [I] . A more complicated one may require three or more cut outs [J]
The trick is to have good colour definition but keeping the contrasts reasonable otherwise its a mess of contrasting colours that obscure the detail in the actual aircraft or vehicle
These examples are sharp edge camo. The blended overspray versions are handled differently depending on the size and colour of the Icon. Sometimes it works......sometimes it doesn't
These have all been expanded 2x normal
https://i.imgur.com/iiIqPua.png
zovs66
July 8th, 2020, 09:50 AM
Wow! I'll just stick to designing scenarios and campaigns, way much easier lol
Karagin
July 8th, 2020, 09:55 AM
Wow! I'll just stick to designing scenarios and campaigns, way much easier lol
Yeah...but sometimes I get this bug that says hey this whatever should look like this. I blame it on my building miniature scifi models and such. Then again I am always tinkering with (breaking) things, so there is that fun.
I have MAYBE 8 icons I have done since figuring out all the fun of this game that I have made that turned out close to what I was going for. And one good thing about this group of folks, everyone is always helpful and there to answer questions. Now if I can convince my air force to STOP attacking its own side...
Imp
July 8th, 2020, 09:58 AM
Gives you an idea of the work involved - there are how many units and many have several different camo schemes, no wonder Don has learned a few tricks.
Awesome.
Imp
July 8th, 2020, 10:00 AM
Now if I can convince my air force to STOP attacking its own side...
At least they look good while they are doing it :)
DRG
July 8th, 2020, 12:19 PM
Don had been finding creative ways to get around the limitations of a restrictive palette and the pixel scale for over two decades!
The palette is only as restrictive as you let it be restrictive. There are some combinations of colours would be nice to have >256 but there are many ways around that.
Every colour here is in the game palette
https://i.imgur.com/w4XqobV.png
Pibwl
July 8th, 2020, 05:55 PM
As a person twiddling only with LBMs, I can only admire your work... :)
DRG
July 8th, 2020, 09:21 PM
here's one you won't see in the game.
https://i.imgur.com/uOGetHB.png
blazejos
July 13th, 2020, 05:16 PM
Great icons of aircrafts!
If this is intresting I d'like to mention about two models of aircrafts in Armée de l’air in 1940 which were used by Polish Army in France too.
Koolhoven F.K.58
https://www.passionair1940.fr/Armee%20de%20l%27Air/Appareils/Chasse/Koolhoven-FK58/Photos/fk58-5.jpg
The story of this Dutch aircraft (https://www.passionair1940.fr/Armee%20de%20l%27Air/Appareils/Chasse/Koolhoven-FK58/EN-Koolhoven-FK58.htm) only 20 from 50 delivered to France before german invasion. Handed to Polish airforce on exile during battle of France.
Technical schematics (http://www.samolotypolskie.pl/uploads/Products/product_1510/Koolhoven_FK-58_rys.jpg)
Koolhoven F.K.58 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koolhoven_F.K.58)
Schematics with painting (https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fi.pinimg.com%2Forigina ls%2Fbd%2F0d%2F6c%2Fbd0d6cd09afa37a618c478b534cbfb 50.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fpl.pinterest.com%2FArthuro _74%2Fkoolhoven-fk58%2F&tbnid=UlpZXMr9ILXgTM&vet=12ahUKEwiDu5D6jcvqAhWFY5oKHU56BooQMygDegUIARCc AQ..i&docid=B2Pn1nvw__tlvM&w=707&h=1000&q=Koolhoven%20F.K.58&client=firefox-b&ved=2ahUKEwiDu5D6jcvqAhWFY5oKHU56BooQMygDegUIARCcA Q)
France & Dutch liveries (https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fi.pinimg.com%2Forigina ls%2F2b%2F14%2F76%2F2b1476859422fcf8419d41d9e2788d 35.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fnl.pinterest.com%2Fpin%2F9 077636728188223%2F&docid=Q1OoSEiDlVY3zM&tbnid=Tq3WyxGwr5snTM&vet=1&w=776&h=1200&itg=1&client=firefox-b&bih=900&biw=1280&ved=2ahUKEwjpiOaUj8vqAhUXxMQBHceRBz8QxiAoAnoECAEQG Q&iact=c&ictx=1)
CAUDRON Cr714
https://www.passionair1940.fr/Armee%20de%20l%27Air/Appareils/Chasse/Caudron-CR714/Photos/Caudron_CR714_C1.jpg
Used only by Polish and Finland
Wikipedia with nice technical schematics (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caudron_C.714)
Photos of polish units aircrafts captured by germans (https://forum.odkrywca.pl/topic/719367-lotnictwo-polskie-we-francji-1940/#comments)
Story of this aircraft model (https://www.passionair1940.fr/Armee%20de%20l%27Air/Appareils/Chasse/Caudron-CR714/EN-Caudron-Cr714.htm)
Technical schematic (http://www.samolotypolskie.pl/uploads/Products/product_641/Caudron_C-714_Cyclone.jpg)
Painting liveries (https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.mojehobby.pl%2Fzdj ecia%2F9%2F9%2F3%2F3024_1-auto_downl.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.mojehobby.pl%2Fproduct s%2FCAUDRON-CR-714.html&tbnid=a5S9WM1XIK46NM&vet=12ahUKEwivh9D7mMvqAhUCyioKHSliC_gQMygBegUIARCk AQ..i&docid=7VsfZKzMhXTahM&w=835&h=572&q=caudron%20cr714&client=firefox-b-ab&ved=2ahUKEwivh9D7mMvqAhUCyioKHSliC_gQMygBegUIARCkA Q)
DRG
July 14th, 2020, 07:00 AM
Great icons of aircrafts!
Thanks
If this is interesting I'd like to mention about two models of aircraft in Armée de l’air in 1940 which were used by the Polish Army in France too.
Koolhoven F.K.58
CAUDRON Cr714
I'll think about it but they were used only as fighters and YES.... we do have others like that already in the game but I give preference to strafers only when the OOB might be short of a bomb carrying ground attack aircraft for a time or it has some historical significance .
The Koolhoven at this scale is almost identical to the Fokker D.XXI
https://i.imgur.com/MgD2ai9.png
( and is armed the same )which I have rebuilt earlier this year
https://i.imgur.com/L8Ay8ar.png
And Yes... they are only strafers as well but they were already in the OOB's
Pibwl
July 14th, 2020, 02:12 PM
By the way, I noticed, that you had tuned up many trucks - great! :up: :)
DRG
July 17th, 2020, 07:14 AM
Here's on you won't see as it was destroyed before it had a chance to be armed and used but I was working on the icon for something to do
CANT z.506
https://i.imgur.com/7qQywFO.png
https://i.imgur.com/xi86Bjc.png
https://i.imgur.com/Ex0RMln.png
Pibwl
July 17th, 2020, 12:30 PM
Here's on you won't see as it was destroyed before it had a chance to be armed and used but I was working on the icon for something to do
CANT z.506
I love it :up: You even cared about asymetrical chequers ;)
Anyway, Kolhooven and CR 714 were very niche fighters and rather weren't used against ground targets. If we'd like to add an interesting aircraft, than maybe LN 411?... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loire-Nieuport_LN.401
blazejos
July 20th, 2020, 03:20 AM
Just found an missing photo for Romanian OOB
RWD-14b "Czapla" polish STOL observation aircraft with folded wings
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-BP0bMD53W8E/XRZ-VtMzA8I/AAAAAAAANi4/csBqS4_zbLIdn0cC2MKIXiMNJDdVY3PfACEwYBhgL/s640/1173823_568465983214285_213490801_n.jpg
RWD-14b in Polish service
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-dA12ElnF0w8/XRZ-SkdT3qI/AAAAAAAANi0/nnoMySRENPUKqj6HihLGX-tjovjYNUVOgCEwYBhgL/s640/rwd.14_11.jpg
Article about
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RWD-14_Czapla
Poland have around 80 of them after 1939 2 were captured by Soviets in Wilno, small number by Germans both sides were not interested and never used them even for testing probably they were scraped by Germans fate of this in Soviet hands in unknown. One interned in Latvia than to Soviets after 1940. One interned by Hungary and used by them
https://www.scalemates.com/products/img/8/1/0/194810-20195-99-pristine.jpg
Between 14 to 17 interned in Romania. In April 1943 was mentioned that they have still 14 of them in service. here is source https://dobroni.pl/artykul/rwd-14-czapla/565021
They have no Bomb racks but each of them was equipped in radio device and two MG one 7,92 mm Vickers F in observation cabin for self-defence. And 7,92 mm PWU wz.33 which shots through engine and propeller for attacking other aircraft's or strafing in pilots disposition.
Icons are already done and inside game shp from about 10 years for polish version and Romania green and brown-green camo with yellow crosses. What is missing that is Czapla with Romanian roundels used before April 1941. What is nice that if we have striking version of Czapla on battlefield which will use this one MG in pilots hands similarly too slow German observation craft which now are also in role of ersatz battlefield support.
DRG
July 20th, 2020, 08:27 AM
Just found an missing photo for Romanian OOB
Thanks...... Now entered
What is missing that is Czapla with Romanian roundels used before April 1941.
Now done
blazejos
July 20th, 2020, 04:15 PM
I'm late for few hours but also worked RWD-14b "Czapla" (Heron). Romanian with roundels is already done faster by you Don thanks :) I'm slower but there are all posible camo's for that aircraft.
Here parked on Sola AF airbase map
- Romanian before 1941 the same which was done by you earlier
- Hungarian they have only one but camo is intresting and propably they use this aircraft in army
- German captured they never even tested them but have a few.
- One of the three capured by Soviets
- And premiere for SPWW2 one Czapla which was interned in Latvia and used by their AF until repainted with red stars .
<blockquote class="imgur-embed-pub" lang="en" data-id="a/m8PNuMZ" data-context="false" ><a href="//imgur.com/a/m8PNuMZ"></a></blockquote><script async src="//s.imgur.com/min/embed.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
There is this story
Just as addon other polish observation aircraft used by Romanians. In 1939 17 of this aircrafts were interned in Romania and included in their AF http://wp.scn.ru/en/ww15/o/235/12/0. One example was in hands of Soviets one in Hungary and one captured by Slovakia. Propably none of them use this antique aircraft except Romanians.
https://i.imgur.com/2cpusiu.png
Small improvment Lublin in both version R.XIIIG hydro & R.XIIID has capacity 6 bombs 12,5kg insdead 4 like is now in OOB. And has only vikers MG in observation cabin. Where I found this? This is other intresting story about exceptional bombing raid on Free city of Danzig in the day when was incorporated to Third Reich.
I just read about an action done by lone polish R.XIIIG hydro
in 7th September 1939 late evening. His mision was bombing BB Schleswig-Holstein near Westerplatte but when he arrived fighting were finished and batleship already gone in darkness as rest of the city. Westerpllate fall during that day but Lublin crew don't know about this. So they flight over dark streets of Danzig old town and by blind luck or rather by torches lights and loud military music suprised german NSDAP victory parade.
In memories of the crew is mentioned that they relase all 6 small bombs inside happy crowd with flags and torches :shock: and use MG from the rear to diperase them.
The link to whole story google translated from polish
https://translate.google.pl/translate?hl=&sl=pl&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Ftysol.pl%2Fa11023-7-wrzesnia-1939-r-%E2%80%93-bomby-na-Parademarsch-Polskie-bombardowanie-lotnicze-Gdanska
https://www.facinghistory.org/sites/default/files/styles/fh_chunk_breakpoints_theme_facing_history_mobile_1 x/public/Ch05_Image01.jpg?itok=bDoa-aeM×tamp=1470247721
Pibwl
July 22nd, 2020, 04:42 PM
Does speed of spotter planes matter?... Accidentally, while checking the Czapla, which was somehow faster than basic Polish spotter Lublin R.XIII, I noticed, that most spotters in the game have speed=1, regardless of their real speed, only few are faster, and Hs 126 is an exception with speed 4 - while not being the fastest plane.
(BTW: Polish 618 LWS Czapla was in fact known mostly as RWD-14 Czapla, as Blazejos mentioned - LWS was only a manufacturer of RWD design)
Here is a quick list that I made, with max speed in km/h (the values are taken from Internet pages and they may vary, but they're enough to give a hint). Cruise speeds, which might be more important, were usually lower by 20-40 km/h in speeds below 200, 40-60 km/h in speeds around 300, and 100-200 km/h in speeds above 500 km/h.
Germany
186 - Fieseler Storch - 175 - 1
187 - Fw 189 Uhu - 374 - 2
410 - He 46 - 257 - 1
589 - Arado Ar-196 - 320 - 3
782 - Hs 126 - 356 - 4
USA:
121 L4 Grasshopper - 140 - 1
360 - Curtiss P-6 - 311 - 1
361 - Curtiss A-12 - 284 - 1
362 - Boeing P-26 - 377 - 1
660 - Douglas O-2 - 216 - 3
USMC
090 - Vought OS2U - 292 - 1
095 - Piper NE-I - <200 - 1
135 - Curtiss P-6 - 311 - 1
136 - Boeing P-26 - 377 - 1
283 - Curtiss Seahawk - 504 - 1
319 - F3F-2 Littlecat - 425 - 1
321 - Douglas OD-l - 216 - 3
UK
114 - Auster Mk.IV - 209 - 1
148 - Lysander - 341 - 1
340 - Hawker Hart - 298 - 3
France
046 - Potez 63.11 - 425 - 3
141 - Auster Mk IV - 209 - 1
231 - L3 Grasshopper - <200 - 1
232 - Potez 25 - 208 - 1
236 - Breguet 19 - 230 - 2
565 - Potez 39 - 249 - 2
566 - Breguet 270 - 236 - 2
567 - ANF Mureaux 110 - 320 - 3
Poland
097 - Auster Mk.IV - 209 - 1
601 - PWS-26 - 201 - 1
603 - Lublin R-XIIIA - 177 - 1
604 - Lublin R-XIIID - 185 - 1
605 - Lublin R-XIIIG - 175 - 1
616 - RWD-8 - 175 - 1
617 - PZL L-2 - 183 - 1
618 - LWS Czapla - 247 - 1
619 - LWS-3 Mewa - 360 - 1
626 - Potez XXV A2 - 208 - 1
Japan ...here we have quick ones:
114 - Mitsubishi F1M - 365 - 4
210 - Aichi D1A - 309 - 3
211 - Aichi E13A1 - 375 - 3
212 - Kokusai Ki-76 - 178 - 2
213 - Yokosuka D4Y1-C - 545 - 6
217 - Nakajima Type91 - 300 - 3
642 - Yokosuka E14Y - 246 - 2
644 - Mitsubishi Ki46 - 604 - 6
645 - Mitsubishi 2MR - 204 - 2
647 - Kawanishi E7K - 276 - 3
648 - Nakajima C6N - 610 - 6
649 - Seversky A8V-1 - 316 - 6
If it's useful, I can check the rest. I can also write down cruise speeds.
Provisionally, I'd suggest speed:
- 1 for aircraft <210 km/h (including Auster, Potez 25 etc with cruise speeds well below 200 km/h)
- 2 for 210-300 km/h
- 3 for 300-400 km/h
- 4 for >400 km/h
I don't think, that any spotter flies much faster performing spotting.
Pibwl
July 22nd, 2020, 04:52 PM
I just read about an action done by lone polish R.XIIIG hydro
in 7th September 1939 late evening. His mision was bombing BB Schleswig-Holstein near Westerplatte but when he arrived fighting were finished and batleship already gone in darkness as rest of the city. Westerpllate fall during that day but Lublin crew don't know about this. So they flight over dark streets of Danzig old town and by blind luck or rather by torches lights and loud military music suprised german NSDAP victory parade.
In memories of the crew is mentioned that they relase all 6 small bombs inside happy crowd with flags and torches :shock: and use MG from the rear to diperase them.
By the way, it would have been an terror bombing against civilians (like the ones performed by the Germans against Wieluń, Warsaw and then British cities, and then by the Western allies...) - but Polish historian Andrzej Olejko indicated slight doubts in 2018, that there are no signs of such attack in German sources - while it might have been used for propaganda...
DRG
July 22nd, 2020, 06:38 PM
Does speed of spotter planes matter?...
MOBHAck help
MOVEMENT - SPEED OF UNITS
Fighter-bomber and level bomber Aircraft Speed: 1 pt of Speed for every 100 km/h (round up past 50)
Spotter Plane/UAV speed is equal to their normal air speed as calculated for fighter-bombers and bombers. The higher the number the wider the circle the Spotter Plane will fly.
Most are one because most fly under 150km/h and keep in mind, aircraft do not have to fly at their max rated combat speed to fly a spotting mission.
....and we found if the spotter planes fly too fast, then the circle gets too wide and they slide off the map so there is code that limits speed and circle diameter built into the game code- so it matters not one little bit if one has 6 speed....... the game will not fly them at that speed . 3 is the max
The speeds they have work well enough.
Pibwl
July 23rd, 2020, 03:09 PM
MOVEMENT - SPEED OF UNITS
...
Spotter Plane/UAV speed is equal to their normal air speed as calculated for fighter-bombers and bombers. The higher the number the wider the circle the Spotter Plane will fly.
I could not find this info and was confused seeing, that almost all have speed 1. And does it affect a probability of being shot down?
Most are one because most fly under 150km/h and keep in mind, aircraft do not have to fly at their max rated combat speed to fly a spotting mission.
....and we found if the spotter planes fly too fast, then the circle gets too wide and they slide off the map so there is code that limits speed and circle diameter built into the game code- so it matters not one little bit if one has 6 speed....... the game will not fly them at that speed . 3 is the max
Thanks for further clarification. It seems I got similar idea, however I thought about 4 :)
The speeds they have work well enough.
As you wish :)
However, some might need small fixes, for consistency ;) The Japanese have no spotter with speed 1, and the Polish with speed above 1, while the oldest US aircraft are the fastest.
blazejos
August 24th, 2020, 12:44 PM
RWD-8
Most numerous of polish small aircraft's, build in 600 number for civilian areo-clubs and for army as trainer, liaison and many other duties. Was also last aircraft's on polish sky used in October 1939 by unit SGO Polesie in their fights against German and Soviets. In this last battles used not only as observation but also as ersatz support with hand-grenades throw by second pilot like in early days of WWI.
https://i.imgur.com/QbEjJXB.png
Here are
- Latvian - 40 of them escape in 1939 were used there and then captured by soviets
-Czechoslovakian small number sold in 1937 there
- Polish gray trainer used as ersatz spotter in 1939
- SP-BHX typical polish civilian
- Nationalist Spain small number sold to gen. Franco army
- SP-BLL polish civilian from areoclub mobilised in 1939
- Soviet small number captured in Poland 1939 then in 1940 captured from
Latvia
- VQ-PAK two used by Hagana as liaison in fight with Palestinians since 1938 destroyed before creation of IAF
- captured German probably used as trainers they have small number of them
- Romanians escaped from Poland 1939 also with roundels before April 1941 used as a trainers and probably liaisons. They have 57 pieces
- Hungarians have 2 pieces which escaped in 1939 used as a liaisons.
blazejos
August 26th, 2020, 06:45 PM
In theme of AOP aircraft's
RWD-13
Probably most successfully polish small aircraft. I add also medical evacuation version RWD-13S.
- Polish military army has no RWD-13 in inventory but mobilised them from areoclubs in September 1939
- Polish ambulance version RWD-13S as was used in 1939 such icon
can be usefully in scenario building representing airfields 1939 together with civilian red rwd-13
Then most of this aircraft's escapes to Romania and Latvia. In 1940 Latvia ocupied by USSR so the were captured by soviets. Romania has around 30 RWD-13 and use them on eastern front in Escadrila albă
rest is the history described in books and even movie from 1944
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Squadron_(Romania)
https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escadrila_Alb%C4%83
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-RF2LXzQEJKk/UFNTPM5LYAI/AAAAAAAABUY/xCoZgh2MNB8/s1600/img001%2B%25282%2529.jpg
Here great documentary movie with English subtitles
https://armed.mapn.ro/escadrila-alba-2625-25
and here link to IMDB
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0035373/
Yugoslavia buy license and produced their own version Rogozarski RVD-13 also in Medical evacuation variant icon already there. Only one survived invasion on Yugoslavia and was letter used by Croatians,
One aircraft escaped from Hel Peninsula to Sweden and were used in army until 1953 and one to Estonia probably letter in Soviet hands.
20 sold to Gen. Franco and used there in Civil war on Nationalist side as AOP aircraft. There was still used even after 1945.
Germans captured some small number intact and used them as liaisons aircraft.
One was a wedding gift from Poland to Shah of Persia and were used by Iranian air force until 1945
Eight were sold to Brazilian army in 1937 and one is still there in museum.
Hagana buy 2 of them in 1937 and used together with RWD-8 as patrol and liaison aircraft they survived until 1947 and were used in Israel war of independence. Probably first aircraft's of IAF.
Soviets have some number of this aircraft's captured in Poland, Latvia and Estonia but is unknown how they used them.
https://i.imgur.com/GcbzAQb.png?1
DRG
August 27th, 2020, 07:49 AM
I may use some of these but not all. The game does not need or use medical evacuation aircraft nor laison and transport aircraft. If it's used for a purpose represented in the game then Maybe it will go in
blazejos
September 1st, 2020, 07:34 PM
Great that some may be usefully.
To finish subject of polish small utility aircraft's used by military RWD-9 aircraft from which evolved mass produced RWD-13. The same machine but with radial engine. Two of them sold to Spain shortly before civil war. Used there on Republican side in artillery observation duties. This lefts in Poland used as civilian aircraft's and destroyed on airfields in September 1939. Two were also used by Czechoslovakian internal affairs Ministry. Probably then in German hands. Also forgoten Rogozarski RVD-8 license build RWD-8 but with radial engine in Yugoslavia.
https://i.imgur.com/xtAfZlw.png
blazejos
September 5th, 2020, 10:16 AM
Some addition in subject of aircraft's
RWD-5
Polish tourist aircraft not in use by army but in desperate days of September 1939 some used by military. One escapes after begin interned in Romania and brings orders for encircled Warszawa in last days of September.
RWD-15
Extended better version of RWD-13 production start in early 1939. Around 7 produced one sold to Hagana shortly before war and destroyed on airfield in 1947 during Israeli war of independence. Rest serve in September 1939 in polish army then escaped to Romania used during war with Soviets around Odessa last still was in Romania in 1947.
RWD-17
Intended as a replacement new version of universal trainer to replace RWD-8&PWS26 in polish army. Around 20 produced many in RWD-17W version. Most never reach MDLot in Puck. Instead together with RWD-17bis served as observation aircraft's then evacuated to Romania were there were in service until late forties. Two were interned in Latvia probably then in Soviets hands.
https://i.imgur.com/rNev6tQ.png
Wibault 7C1
French versions also with Naval used on only French aircraft carrier Bearn. Polish license build PZL Wibault 7C1. And Vickers license build 7C1 with radial engine for Chile and with water cooled engine 73 version for Paraguay used in Gran-Chaso war. Paraguay has the same roundel as French so is hard to distinct only by ruder. Hope that Chilean and Paraguayan version maby of same use for scenario creation in green or blue OOB.
PZL Ł-2
Polish observation aircraft used before Lublin finally Lublin R-XIII were chosen because was cheaper to manufacture than Ł-2 and PZL instead start to produce fighters.
PZL P-1 & PZL P-6 & PZL P-8
P-1 was an machine which start the family of famous in early thirties Puławski's fighters. P-6 was an evolution step to use radial engines from which P-7a evolved and P-8 was the last and best but unfortunately in Poland the were never produced water cooled engines so wasn't directed to production by PZL. They were prototypes but will be nice to have them in early thirties to show from which aircraft's polish fighter's evolved.
https://i.imgur.com/6518QGN.png
DRG
September 5th, 2020, 10:30 AM
I added the CANT z.506 to the Polish OOB because I already had an Icon for it and the Poles had one ( 1 ) and I thought I'd add it as a "fun" what-if?.
That addition was not intended to inspire a flood of obscure Polish sport planes and prototypes that might or not have been used during WW2. That CANT z.506 was added as an afterthought at the end of my interest in adding more aircraft to the game so if you're having fun building these then by all means continue as I know how addictive it can be ( 3x as many of mine get rejected than get added into the SHP files )........but don't expect they will be added to the master game.
blazejos
September 6th, 2020, 03:35 PM
Hello
Know that may be tiresome but I try cover all this aircraft's which aren't in polish OOB because were small and not strict military. I don't expect that you found all icons usefully I start to paint them because such activity have fun factor like model building as you mentioned that. Use that what may be usefully for game and simple left the rest they are just propositions.
But still I imagine some scenario for example with Romanian RWD-13 medical evacuation but that will require some hardcoded addition and new class like Landing Aircraft.
RWD-13 may land like now in game code gilder but with different sound of engine and without variation in place of landing just simple land on airfield in exact place. Then player must lead infantry as cover unit and valuable unit with wounded soldiers to aircraft. When wounded are loaded for example we my have in the same place were now hovering button for helicopter a launch button and in next turn our aircraft simple lift out and go out map so made a reverse trip of gilder. I know that such functionality need a change in game code but will be great to have such missions as air landing attack where Ju52 land on airfields and solders instead of using parachute just simple go out from aircraft or evacuate that way from airfield.:happy:
Pibwl
September 6th, 2020, 04:06 PM
Some addition in subject of aircraft's
Wibault 7C1
French versions also with Naval used on only French aircraft carrier Bearn. Polish license build PZL Wibault 7C1. And Vickers license build 7C1 with radial engine for Chile and with water cooled engine 73 version for Paraguay used in Gran-Chaso war. Paraguay has the same roundel as French so is hard to distinct only by ruder. Hope that Chilean and Paraguayan version maby of same use for scenario creation in green or blue OOB.
PZL Ł-2
Polish observation aircraft used before Lublin finally Lublin R-XIII were chosen because was cheaper to manufacture than Ł-2 and PZL instead start to produce fighters.
We already have them in the OOB... ;)
(albeit PZL Ł-2 has similar icon of Lublin R-XIII, and Wibault has an unknown similar icon - Blazej's is more accurate indeed)
DRG
September 6th, 2020, 07:02 PM
I will use what I consider to be appropriate to use and if they upgrade an existing Icon or replace one that was used as a "good enough" a decade ago they will be used
blazejos
November 22nd, 2020, 05:48 PM
Don I really like your icons of Spad S.51 and S.61. So I made some investigation and paint some icons based on yours
Bleriot SPAD S.51 in all variants and engine slighty modified. Also Avia and Nakaima build this aircraft on license
-Spanish Republic
-Turkish
-Japan build by Nakaima
-French
-Soviet (only used in trials)
-Czechslovakia with square national symbols used in between 1920-1930 manufactured by Avia
-Polish
-Spain Nationalists (after war started)
-China
-Spain Republicans (also before war)
https://i.imgur.com/8EXuaUd.png
Bleriot SPAD S.61 straight wings and water-cooled engine only used by Poland and Romania
Bleriot SPAD S.81 only used by France
Bleriot SPAD S.91 used by France and Spain (Republicans after start of civil war)
DRG
November 25th, 2020, 12:14 PM
some I may use where they might be useful to the game but I can find no info anywhere on a Nakaima copy of the SPAD 51
DRG
November 26th, 2020, 05:11 PM
The saga of modeling obscure aircraft into the game continues.
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16200&stc=1&d=1606424927
This one actually fills a niche in the early years of the game and it's so ugly it's beautiful. I had some time to kill yesterday so I created one as I hadn't built an icon since the end of the first lockdown this year and I was looking for something "unique"
The Dornier N was a bomber aircraft designed in Germany in the 1920s which started in production in Japan in 1927. The aircraft were built as the Kawasaki Ka 87 which was also referred to as the Type 87 Night Bomber.*
*
It was designed and built as a landplane but its layout is very similar to the Dornier flying boats of the same period and was a parasol-wing, strut-braced monoplane with two engines mounted in a push-pull nacelle above the wing. Some of the 28 examples that were built saw action in Manchuria in 1931.*
*
Despite it's slow speed, poor stability and limited payload it's design and construction helped the Japanese gain much-needed experience in the construction of all-metal aircraft and it remained in limited service in Manchuria and Korea until modern replacements entered service in 1937.*
blazejos
November 27th, 2020, 01:54 PM
nice icon of Kawasaki Ka 87 really great aircraft. That also remainds me about Soviet Beriev MBR-2
https://topwar.ru/uploads/posts/2019-07/thumbs/1562792961_mbr2-14.jpg
https://topwar.ru/uploads/posts/2019-07/thumbs/1562792940_mbr2-3.jpg
Main maritime flying boat of Soviet Union. Which before WW2 was declared obsolete but from lack of any better aircraft take part in war on North Sea, Baltic, Black Sea and Pacific. After WW2 all were send to North Korea where was in use until 1952 used to maritime patrol and in night bombing raids on Americans troops on ground. The were practically stealth for radars in interceptors thanks to their wooden construction.
Whole story of this flying boat
https://en.topwar.ru/160022-boevye-samolety-mbr-2-ambarchik-berieva.html
http://wio.ru/tacftr/hydro.htm
DRG
November 27th, 2020, 05:16 PM
WIP.............
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16202&stc=1&d=1606512116
First final
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16204&stc=1&d=1606513157
Ver 2
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16205&stc=1&d=1606522115
Finland
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16208&stc=1&d=1606522644
blazejos
November 28th, 2020, 07:22 AM
Fantastic icon and how you done that so nearly instantly.
:up:
If you looked on both previous photos there were two variants of MBR-2 with M-17B engine open cockpit ant without turret in rear and newer variant probably introduced somewhere during war 1941/1942 don't know exactly with M-34NB engine. Table show differences between both versions http://wio.ru/tacftr/hydro.htm looks main difference was in celling and range not in bombs load.
Early variant schematics
https://airpages.ru/draw/mbr2_17.gif
Late variant schematics
https://airpages.ru/draw/mbr2_34.gif
And for the end variant for SPMBT rather than SPWW2 MBR-2 in North Korea can't find any picture but have a nice model
http://massimotessitori.altervista.org/sovietwarplanes/board/index.php?topic=1999.0
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7358/16301316210_b7707d1f8a_o.jpg
Acording to this picture Finland has also an older variant
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/proxy/KpOVOTr5hh55q9LBonexjjusGr_LY1kChGHqdYfqIk6WGHvIeU mmquvvbGPZg_OGDveaEZlZDG-C5zkX6TLlnrvSC80SLLw
But also use the new one and was an only operator outside soviet union during WW2 there is also Finland winter camo
http://wp.scn.ru/en/ww2/h/380/78/0
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/52/90/16/5290168d53c6da23ee516c26ef82df9d.jpg
There is if that is interesting specific nice camo use by Northern Fleet something like blue with silver(white)
https://www.mojehobby.pl/zdjecia/5/8/3/1635_rd.jpg
DRG
November 28th, 2020, 08:43 AM
:D
http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=16210&stc=1&d=1606579140
That is the Revision. I noticed after building it that the engine was set back too far so they all have been revised to correct that error now.
Ts4EVER
December 10th, 2020, 01:37 PM
Just a little idea I had:
Everyone knows that the German toe is completely full. Recently I remembered that the Fallschirmjäger in this game are weirdly split up, with 3 "normal" inf groups and 3 lmg groups. Now afaik the FJG Squad had two light machine guns in real life. Is this ingame organisation some kind of holdover from an earlier version of the game that lacked the "2 MG34" / "2 MG42" weapons?
Because it seems like the TOE could be streamlined by getting rid of the lmg teams and instead just giving the infantry teams two lmgs. No idea how much other trouble this would cause on older scenarios, but might be a possibility to clear up space in the German list.
DRG
December 10th, 2020, 02:28 PM
It would only open 5 slots and create problems I have no interest in creating for myself. If those were removed then every formation that uses them would need to be redone by adding an extra FJg Gruppe so that what was two separate units would now be one in the formation
The FJg LMG Grp was put in (IIRC from 22 years ago) to give the FJ a bit more flexibility and firepower for deployment by dividing up one FJg Gruppe to create 2 FJg LMG Grp ( like USMC fireteams ) so we could dumb down the game to "gain" 5 slots but every scenario and campaign that currently uses FJg would need to be redone AND they would have to be redone creatively because what was two units is now one unit would be missing from the unit ID list for every scenario and campaign that uses them.
Not to mention the FJg LMG [G] is as formtion that only uses the units that would be removed which leaves gaps in higher formations that use it which would have to be tracked down and redone
And for what ? To gain 5 slots.......what exactly are we missing from the game that would benfit by having those 5 slots ? There are already 3 empty ones in the current OOB and have been for a couple of years
Ts4EVER
December 10th, 2020, 02:30 PM
Ok, makes sense then.
blazejos
December 24th, 2020, 09:01 AM
some I may use where they might be useful to the game but I can find no info anywhere on a Nakaima copy of the SPAD 51
Nakaima 51C1
This is were I found this No photo only this schematics from Czech model manufacturer
https://www.pinterest.cl/pin/45036065008287126/
DRG
December 24th, 2020, 09:08 AM
some I may use where they might be useful to the game but I can find no info anywhere on a Nakaima copy of the SPAD 51
Nakaima 51C1
This is were I found this No photo only this schematics from Czech model manufacturer
https://www.pinterest.cl/pin/45036065008287126/
When I Google "Nakaima 51C1" nothing much comes back which for Japanese aircraft is highly unusual. The only thing is a copy of the one you found
https://www.net-maquettes.com/az-model/bleriot-spad-51c1-az-model-legato-7226/
so I'm thinking this was something the Japanese evaluated only. They did that alot in the 20's but there is no mention of even that on any source about the SPAD
blazejos
January 26th, 2021, 01:58 PM
I d'like to add some research about PZL P-X Puławski fighter series especially in outside Poland service. Most of the icons already existing inside game so was necessary just to add small number of them and some pictures. I also add research OOB for tests.
Just the new icons without this already inside game
https://i.imgur.com/iZXejTu.png
Poland
early prototypes like
PZL P-1
PZL P-6
PZL P-7 prototypes
PZL P-8
PZL P-11 prototype
There is also PZL P-11a which was manufactured in number aroud 30 and was a somothing like hybrid between P-7a&P-11c has P-7a parts of hull but engine like P-11.
P-11g Kobuz was an interim fighter build in spring of 1939 P-11c hull and wings. Engine which was stocked for PZL P-50 Jastrząb and because problems with this new fighter prototype In spring 1939 was made decision to produce this hybrids. Manufacturing started but they were not finished until september 1939. Only one was completed and used in fights 11 September 1939. Rest of the series uncompleted were lost. Propably Germans when captured PZL factory send them to scrap.
PZL P-24 protoptypes which was base for export aircraft in factory until 1939. P-24bis prototype with french 20mm guns sold to Abisynia (modern Ethiopia in 1936) as legend said was moust modern aircraft which they have during war against Italy.
PZL P-24F & H & J were models proposed by PZL for polish airforce in late 30th with french engines never acepted by Military aviation to serial production. Because there were concept of moder fighter P-50 Jastrząb. Shortly before war in summer PZL
was asked for manufacture P-24J for Poland but was alredy too late to start production.
Romania
Bigest user of polish aircraft before war they buy in Poland PZL P-11b and PZL P-24E. Manufactured their own IAR P-11f and IAR P-24E and their enginers based on P-24 license and parts designed their own IAR-80 ultimate evolution of P-X planes line.
As a neutral country in 1939 they interned many Polish aircraft from 1939 and used them in their AF during war.
PZL P-7a polish interned they were quite obsolete used as a trainers and strafing
- ground atack in early Barbarossa around Odessa and in Besarabia then after 1941 only as trainers
PZL P-11a also polish interned used in ground atack role like P-7a then relegated to training only
PZL P-11b their own obsolete aircraft used together with P-7a&P-11a then after 1941 only for training
IAR P-11f romunian manufactured aircraft equal to P-11c with french engine used as fighter and ground atack role in Barbarossa
and then on Crimea until half of 1942 then relegated as trainer and taken back in 1944 to active duty
during Romania homeland defense again in ground atack role.
PZL P-11c polish interned aircrafts they were used together with P-11f last time in desperate defense in 1944
PZL P-24E & IAR P-24E Romania buy them as a aircraft which was a base for construction of their own IAR-80
and as a interim fighter. They were in use until half of 1942 in southern Ukraine and Crimea. Then relegated to training
and taken back to defend Romania in 1944.
Hungary
Has one P-11a interned and shortly used in their AF then relegated as gilder tug
Germany
The have captured on Dęblin airfield around 10 P-7a intact which they used in their training school. Itrestingly they haven't taken any number of P-11 because they were wreckage or escaped to neutral countries. So they only have one P-11c in museum in Berlin
Soviet Union
They captured a small number of P-11c and P-7a more than one piece but propably not more than 10 they also captured in 1940 this which were interned in Latvia 1939. Because type was not intresting for research old aircraft they were used as trainers untill barbarossa when were lost.
Turkey
They buy aircraft from Poland three models PZL P-24A &C&G they also buy license and manufactured them in factory TFK used as a fighters until 1943 then as a trainers. They still have 2 of them in museum. Model C is intresting because was only P-24 with 20mm guns which has also bombs.
Greece
They buy in Poland aircrafts in variants PZL P-24A &F &G they were in silver natural finish until Italian agresion in November 1940
Then repainted in camo. Around February 1941 there were lack of ammo and spare parts for french 20mm guns so F variant start to be rearmed to 4x 7.92mm MG
Also around that times Greek roundels was painted by camo on top of wings like in soviet war camo schematics. Last working Greek fighter were evacuated to Alexandria from Crete when island fall.
Bulgaria
They buy in Poland aircraft PZL P-24B &F last delivered in August 1939 with 20mm canons used until summer 1944 in last years as a trainers when they were totally obsolete. Saw some combat aginst comunist partisants in 1944 in ground atack role. Never used against American bombers in 1944 were then too slow.
Abisynia
One Prototype P-24bis sold to this country 1936 legends say that were used then as fighter and ground-atack role during war with Italian and there lost. Italian did not capture any P-24. Poland also has good international relations with Italy before war so is possible that such transaction was kept secret.
DRG
January 27th, 2021, 11:27 AM
I have moved this thread to MODS as it has devolved into a MODS thread. Any further posts like the one above need to be in the MODs thread where they belong. I am really ( really ) not interested in putting captured training aircraft into the official game OOBs even if they might-maybe have been used in combat at some point. Anyone who feels different can pick them up and use them in their own custom OOB with the tools provided with the game.
blazejos
March 12th, 2021, 04:47 PM
This new icons are probably not worth much because they represents trainers meaby except Ethiopian P-24. But if you looked inside OOB there were aircraft used in normal combat.
Especially in my opinion worth to consider P-7/P-11/P-24 in Romanian service in ground attack role in early Barbarossa and then in 1944 they have their own P-11b/IAR P-11f/IAR P-24E and most of ex-Polish aircraft which wasn't destroyed in 1939 P-7a/P-11c.
Turkey aircraft in Blue/Green OOB that was standard fighter in this country 1937-1942 in three version. They have also only version of aircraft with 20mm & bombs
Greece I made more precise versions and change of painting after Italian invasion from silver to Green-Brown also without Greek roundels on top of wings like in soviets aircraft's after German invasion probably not applied an all aircraft's. And also is covered fact that there were not enough spare parts to 20mm canons and this variant were rearmed to MG only close to the end of Greece defensive war.
Bulgaria has two variants one with 20mm guns and second with MG that was main fighter of this country 1938-1941. Bulgarians fighters saw no major fights until 1944 when they were obsolete and used in ground attack role against communists partisans similar to usage by Romanians.
BTW P-24 was most widely exported and used Polish aircraft in pre-war times and that is why try to fine-tune data about versions and onboard weapons.
vBulletin® v3.8.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.