.com.unity Forums
  The Official e-Store of Shrapnel Games

This Month's Specials

Bronze - Save $7.00
Raging Tiger - Save $7.00

   







Go Back   .com.unity Forums > The Camo Workshop > WinSPWW2 > TO&Es
Notices


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old March 5th, 2011, 12:02 AM
Roman's Avatar

Roman Roman is offline
Second Lieutenant
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Córdoba-Argentina
Posts: 462
Thanks: 9
Thanked 14 Times in 14 Posts
Roman is on a distinguished road
Default 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

When I have played Germany the flak 88 works as anti-tank , but I think he is not working as flak. I'll try again to see if I'm wrong.
I have heard that this gun was also used as field artillery.
If so, no way to be used for bombing?
Yet I know that his best performance was as a anti-tank. In the rest was poor.
__________________
Greeting
Roman.
Argentina 2014 World Cup champion
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old March 5th, 2011, 03:09 AM
Mobhack's Avatar

Mobhack Mobhack is offline
General
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Dundee
Posts: 4,902
Thanks: 13
Thanked 985 Times in 692 Posts
Mobhack is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Roman View Post
When I have played Germany the flak 88 works as anti-tank , but I think he is not working as flak. I'll try again to see if I'm wrong.
I have heard that this gun was also used as field artillery.
If so, no way to be used for bombing?
Yet I know that his best performance was as a anti-tank. In the rest was poor.
The 88mm in the game is being used as an anti-tank gun. When this was done, they were usually stripped of all the barrage directors and so on, and were deployed individually in A/T positions to engage tanks, not deployed as a centralised battery, grouped round an AAA predictor and connected up with cables etc.

There is absolutely no point in any sort of AAA version, since it was used for barrage fire at level bombers at medium to high altitudes. Attack planes are down low, where the lighter flack is required to deal with them. The 88 does not do that since it cannot track fast targets.

Wasting a unit class as "heavy flak" which could only fire at level bombers would be a total waste of time. How often does your PBEM opponent use level bombers on you?. (The AI does not use the class, which was really only created for scenario designers to write Normandy Breakout type scenarios with).

Andy
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old March 5th, 2011, 02:22 PM
Roman's Avatar

Roman Roman is offline
Second Lieutenant
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Córdoba-Argentina
Posts: 462
Thanks: 9
Thanked 14 Times in 14 Posts
Roman is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Ok. Thanks for the reply.
__________________
Greeting
Roman.
Argentina 2014 World Cup champion
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old December 3rd, 2011, 11:09 PM
manteuffel's Avatar

manteuffel manteuffel is offline
Private
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Germany
Posts: 32
Thanks: 12
Thanked 5 Times in 3 Posts
manteuffel is on a distinguished road
Medal Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Funny that you bring that up. I noticed that the 88 was used quite frequently as artillery by the Germans but I'm sure it was in a different configuration. I think one example of the 88 being used as artillery that comes to mind is during the shelling of the encircled 101st airborne division.

Here is an interesting documentary about the 88
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1C7Hl28MHio
__________________
“You cannot be disciplined in great things and indiscipline in small things. Brave undisciplined men have no chance against the discipline and valor of other men. Have you ever seen a few policemen handle a crowd?”
-General George S. Patton Jr
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old December 4th, 2011, 12:15 AM
Mobhack's Avatar

Mobhack Mobhack is offline
General
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Dundee
Posts: 4,902
Thanks: 13
Thanked 985 Times in 692 Posts
Mobhack is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Adding such would simply add another unit to an already crowded OOB. But they would cost about the same as a 105mm battery, so 99% of players would pay the few points more for the greater shell size.

The British in Burma tended to use the 3.7 inch batteries as long range arty as well, due to lack of trade in the AA role. But adding a "3.7 used as arty" battery would also clutter a crowded OOB, and be of the same effect as the existing 25 pounder battery really.

What can't be modelled in the game (for off map units) is the extremely flat trajectory of such high velocity AAA guns. They basically could only fire at hill-tops and other such LOS targets visible from the rear areas. So best ignored, or simply buy some on-map 88s and snipe from the rear areas at what you can see with direct HE especially if playing a larger map. (And if you are going to spend those points - then why not just buy a 105mm, again? - at least it can fire indirect, as well as having a bigger bang).

Cheers
Andy
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old December 6th, 2011, 07:51 AM
RecruitMonty's Avatar

RecruitMonty RecruitMonty is offline
Captain
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Mainly Germany (München)
Posts: 808
Thanks: 166
Thanked 86 Times in 55 Posts
RecruitMonty is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Thanks for the detailed response Andy.

I happened upon this post after reading the one on the MBT forum about the Patriot Missiles. As far as I know in MBT this type of AA asset gets more use. Now, from what I read there, I understood that it has a similar role to what an 8,8cm gun would have in WW2 if it were implemented. I was wondering if it would be possible to develop the 8,8 etc as AAA for MBT in the OOB mod I am working on. If so, then what class of unit should I put them under in your opinion? Any thought would be appreciated.
__________________
"Wir Deutschen sollten die Wahrheit auch dann ertragen lernen, wenn sie für uns günstig ist."
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old December 6th, 2011, 09:30 AM
Mobhack's Avatar

Mobhack Mobhack is offline
General
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Dundee
Posts: 4,902
Thanks: 13
Thanked 985 Times in 692 Posts
Mobhack is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Every now and then some bright spark comes along asking why these "AA guns" don't shoot at random planes, and I answer them.

So please search the forums and you will see the various responses.

But (ho hum, here we go yet again) - for a brief over view, one last time - later responses will be along the lines of "search the **g forum posts"

- 88mm and others used special AA predictors and fired in barrage mode at medium and high level bomber formations. These predictors were not mounted on the guns. The predictor connected up to the guns with cables, so the guns required to be within a few metres of the predictor equipment.

- The medium AA guns do not have individual AA sights! (unlike 20mm etc). (The 3.7 inch had absolutely no sights other than the pointer dials 2 different gun numbers used to follow the predictor input. I have seen a picture of a detached 3.7 at Tobruk with a simple lash-up sight ring brazed onto the gun tube)

- 88mm guns in the game are distributed as anti tank guns dotted about the countryside. The AAA predictor is nowhere nearby, it would be useless in the ATG role, and would not have miles of cable to connect to the medium AA which are sited for AT work, not out in the open in a gun line as for AAA. The sights and fire control on the in-game guns are the direct fire telescope for firing at ground targets, and not what any AAA predictor model would be (rather lower stats - area flak is not very accurate). Dual sights are not an option in SP, so these anti-air 88s would be less use than the ATG model in game terms, for plinking at tanks. And would have little Ap ammo, anyway.

- Medium AAA did not fire at low level strike aircraft. They simply could not follow such high tracking rate targets. GE 88mm battalions often had 20mm AAA attached to protect them from low fliers...

I have seen both the 88 and the 3.7 inch at IWM Duxford, they are displayed near each other. Even if the 88 is a 'little baby' beside the hugeness of the 3.7, it is still a lumbering great thing. Bigger than a 25 pounder field gun. Manual traverse just would not allow following a strafer, though it was enough to follow lumbering high level bombers. (The USA 75mm powered traverse Skysweeper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skysweeper was an over-complex approach to medium AAA in the jet age in the 50s. It failed).

- Apart from the level bomber class, all SP planes are low level strafing 'Jabos'...

So, what use is a gun that will only be able to fire at the one-pass level bomber class, and otherwise be less accurate for engaging ground targets, especially in an OOB that is completely crowded already?.

And of course, if we did this for the Germans, then everyone else would wail that OMG they needed their 3.7 or 85mm medium AAA pieces. Because wargamers are like that, especially the rivet counter types.

And after al the work of shoehorning in a medium AAA class, then they would be used about as often as the level bomber class - the only thing they are useful for shooting at. In other words, slightly above nil usefulness.

However, every 6 months or so, a bright spark will have the wonderful 'new' idea of introducing 88mm AAA guns to the game.

For recursion, see recursion.

Andy
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old December 6th, 2011, 11:39 AM
RecruitMonty's Avatar

RecruitMonty RecruitMonty is offline
Captain
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Mainly Germany (München)
Posts: 808
Thanks: 166
Thanked 86 Times in 55 Posts
RecruitMonty is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Right, well, I wasn't asking anyone here to do it for me but never mind. I was simply wondering how I would go about doing something similar to the Patriot for MBT with larger Flak in fixed positions for a fortified line in a series of scenarios that I will be working on for my "das Reich" mod. It is therefore not for the vanilla game.

In this set of scenarios large numbers of "level bombers" will be used by the enemy and I was interested in providing both missile and gun defenses to deal with a portion of these. Lighter AA like 20mm and 37mm will not really fulfill that role for the level bombers. In MBT there is more scope and the OOBs are less crowded so I will be implementing something like this if I can. All I needed was a suggestion from you regarding which unit classes to look at in the new MBT OOBs. It has been a while since I did OOB work as I have spent more time making new icons but I guess I'll just figure it out myself.

As it is I have read the previous posts, agree wholeheartedly and therfore have no desire to see any 88 etc added to either WW2 or MBT in an AAA role. I was merely asking for some advice on my own OOB work.
__________________
"Wir Deutschen sollten die Wahrheit auch dann ertragen lernen, wenn sie für uns günstig ist."
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old December 6th, 2011, 01:12 PM
Mobhack's Avatar

Mobhack Mobhack is offline
General
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Dundee
Posts: 4,902
Thanks: 13
Thanked 985 Times in 692 Posts
Mobhack is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Heavy SAM can reach level bombers in MBT. This is the WW2 forum, however, and the class is not implemented here.

If your mod is using MBT as a base - then please ask about things in the MBT forum, or it gets confusing.

Andy
Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to Mobhack For This Useful Post:
  #10  
Old May 3rd, 2012, 10:24 AM
RecruitMonty's Avatar

RecruitMonty RecruitMonty is offline
Captain
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Mainly Germany (München)
Posts: 808
Thanks: 166
Thanked 86 Times in 55 Posts
RecruitMonty is on a distinguished road
Default Re: 88 antitank, antiaircraft and artillery?

Will do.
__________________
"Wir Deutschen sollten die Wahrheit auch dann ertragen lernen, wenn sie für uns günstig ist."
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:25 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©1999 - 2017, Shrapnel Games, Inc. - All Rights Reserved.