Well to clarify, Devil's advocate would have been more appropriate for what I think of Nagot's stance. I know he likes to argue
Ok, so your crappy cataphracts saved your day because they were size 3 and not 2. Does it proves that they are not subpar? That they find a use in 0.1% of the situation is rather the proof they have a very small window of opportunity.
btw, what are the exact damages of a light lance, the description says 'dependant charge bonus' ???