OT Which would you Choose

[MrToxin]

Randallw said:
Friendly warning. It's not too wise to mention the latest Dune books to die hard Dune fans. I'll admit they're the only ones I've really read and they were entertaining enough, if lacking in some areas, but recent Dune books are to die hard Dune fans as the SW prequels are to die hard SW fans . Me, I take what I can from things and don't let faults bother me.

Well apart from mixing genres and unsympathetic "good guys"

Amazing writer or not, Mr. Herbert Jr. was nice enough to take the time to tell us all the stuff that lead up to the Dune universe.

I'll take that.

[Hugh Manatee]

Didn't Herbert sr. do that in the first book though? It's in the appendix