OT: Malazan Book of the Fallen

[Kristoffer O]

If they cost more points they will have less magic, as magic costs points.

[thejeff]

Dragons are the only pretenders that have to pay for magic they can't use. All the other monster type pretenders have full access to their paths in battle, Dragons either have to start as a vulnerable human and shift or not have full use of the magic they paid for. Including, I'd assume, the side benefits of high paths: attack bonus and the like.

On the other hand it's a neat ability and it distinguishes them. And does have the advantage of full slots for ritual casting and forging.

Overall, it's a disadvantage. Maybe instead of losing 2 levels, they could lose 1 in dragon form and gain one in human from the actual purchased value?

[MaxWilson]

thejeff said:
Overall, it's a disadvantage. Maybe instead of losing 2 levels, they could lose 1 in dragon form and gain one in human from the actual purchased value?

Note that this is currently moddable with the #magicboost command.

-Max

[HoneyBadger]

I don't think dragons should be ultra ultra uber, either, but the most powerful of them should definitely be some of the most powerful units in the game.

A determined human can kill anything-we've defeated cave bears, Hitler, polio, neanderthals, the rocky mountain locust, and dying before we're 30...and dragons should have vulnerabilities, but they should be vulnerable like a tank or a jet fighter is vulnerable.

Kristoffer, considering that dragons love treasure so much, would there be a way that, through empowerment, they could automatically shapechange? Like say a red dragon that, once it's been empowered to fire 6, for instance, turns into a stronger unit? That way, instead of over time, they could become stronger at a significant cost of gems.

[Stryke11]

While thier length is intimidating, I can honestly say these are the best epic fantasy books I have ever read. Typically people praise them for their grittiness, and fantasy-realism (if that even makes sense) but I rather find that they are exceptional in the way they flow and the characterizations.

No one who enjoys adventure can say that the Chain of Dogs wasn't just awesome and heartrending at the same time. the siege of Capustan was shocking but so well portrayed it really seemed like you were there, and all hope was lost.

My one complaint is an echo of what was stated earlier, that everyone and their brother is immortal, and the power balance is a bit screwy. Karsa is one tough mother, sure, but if he can be captured by humans and for a short time enslaved, then I'm not buying that he can also take down gods. Some uber characters are justified in terms of the story, like Anomander Rake, but not all of them. Plus the fact that every tribe and group of people skulking around in a wasteland has their own super powerful gods and an entire race of people (the Wickans) have the potential for immortality. SPOILERS: Chain of Dogs would have meant even more if Coltaine actually died, like, for real. It was moving that he took up so many ravens or whatnot to carry his soul, but that was just unnecessary.

Still, from a lyrical standpoint, nothing compares. And unlike other "epic" fantasy writers, I think Erikson is actually going to finish what he started, and in a timely manner.

[MaxWilson]

Hmmm. What does it mean to die "for real" in the Malazan universe? To put it another way, if I believe in an afterlife, does that mean that I can't find joy and sorrow when a man gives his life for his friends?

I think the Wickans are emphatically NOT exceptional in the Malazan universe. Hood is exceptional in that he actually collects dead souls and does something with them, which I think is quite decent of him.

-Max

[Stryke11]

I guess when I say die "for real" what I mean is being taken out of the tapestry of history, and even if your soul lives on elsewhere, being unable to affect events in the mortal world. By that standard Coltaine is actually one of the least offensive, as while he was "reborn", it was as a child and it will take many years for him to grow and become relevant again.

Compare to: Paran, Silverfox, Tool, The Bridgeburners (in spirit form), the Malazan historian (can't spell his name, etc. who die and yet immediately come back and are able to impact events.

[MaxWilson]

Kristoffer O said:
If they cost more points they will have less magic, as magic costs points.

Is there a method, by the way, for determining how much pretender chassises pay for their starting magic paths? It's always cheaper to buy S10E3 for an Oracle than a Cyclops, for instance, and so it's not clear how much the Oracle's starting S3 actually "costs."

-Max