What's wrong with this?

[Mobhack]

I tried that after my post, and that was the one wanted.

Another oddity here, and I have tried several test PBEM campaign starts (to ensure it is actually using the same code as the battle generator!). Which it is.

The battle location for your game 1 was "0 - Northern Europe", which is completely wrong for that pair and date. None of my experiments were able to generate this whatsoever. All dialled up the correct batlocs for Turkey/Greece (Various of Turkey, Greece, Cyprus). No Northern Europe. So something strange must be going on at your end, I presume...

Are both of you on the exact same game version?

You are using a brand new zip file for each email message, and not trying to reuse an existing zip (that has caused problems in the past).

And I presume both of you are using zip files - not one sending RAR and the other zips?

If you start a test battle in your game with the battle generator for that pair and date you (both) should see turkey, greece, cyprus. Not Northern Europe.

Hmm - did someone load up a custom map or something?. (but it generates a 0 - Northern Europe on the next battle of that campaign, so something is definitely corrupted).

Cheers
Andy