Would this be considered a bug ?

[velk]

Originally posted by johan osterman:
The effect will be no different from if he had a lower starting hitpoint to begin with, ie 50hp -20% =40hp, these 40hp would then be reduced by enemy dominions if applicable. Pretender/prophet HP is reduced by 20% per enemy dominion step, but it stops at 1hp. Since he won't die from it it seems a little odd to call it a bug. [/QB]

My concern was that the way that the two effects stacked seemed to be additive.

I.e. - from your own example :

With a 50 hp prophet, an 80% dominion penalty would reduce their hp to 10, and a 20% never healing wound would reduce that by another 10 to 0 ( or 1 with the mechanism you described above ).

On the other hand, a 40hp prophet with an 80% dominion penalty would have their hp reduced to 8.

Logically the never healing wound should reduce their *current* maximum hp by 20% rather than their *base* maximum hp, then both examples would end up at 8hp.