Balance issue: order-luck, a no brainer?

[apoger]

>The formula players who know every algebraic equation for the game wouldnt tend to like luck because of the randoms it tosses in.

I consider myself to be one of those guys, and in Dom1 I was a huge advocate of luck +3. I didn't mind the randomness. I just considered that the effects would naturally even out statistically over time.

Sadly in Dom2 it looks like I am now an advocate of Misfortune +3. It's my opinion that IW was too heavy handed in their treatment of the scales. There is just as much imbalance now as there was before. Just the emphasis has shifted.