Hall of Shame

[moderation]

vfb said:
moderation, it's your right to play in games where NAPs are always honored. It sounds like it would be a good idea for you to start some games like that, or at least check that that's a condition of the games that you join.

But I have no idea why you are linking to Sheap's tips in your signature when you seem to disagree with every single point he makes in Tip 1:

Sheap: 1.1) Don't berate the other players
moderation: People who make up flimsy roleplaying excuses for bull**** need not apply.

I understood what Sheap said as "Don't berate the other players [for something they do in a game]." In any case, this is not a game thread and I reserve the right to call bull when I see it. You may want to read the above posts like #591195 to see why I'm annoyed. I do my best to make clear arguments, but I also reserve the right to get angry with irrelevant ad hominem attacks.

I think the idea of a generally accepted code of conduct to be a good idea. Getting everyone to agree on what those rules should be of course, is more difficult. I adopted Sheap's Tips in the absence of anything else. But after some consideration, I have formulated different opinions for reasons listed above. I just find inappropriate roleplaying more problematic than no roleplaying. I find Tips 2 and 3 to still be useful though.