Adjudication on a NAP -edited please comment again

[zenphos]

Aaaah, but it is not his opinion I care about. It is the opinion of the forum as a whole.
I would not want my opponent to flood the boards with what an untrustworthy fellow I am and find myself having trouble finding allies in other games. So that is one reason I submitted this question.
The other is while I think I am in the right my view is some what biased and, being honourable arcoscephale, it would be wrong to break any sort of agreement in the game.
Now if I was one of the evil, untrustworthy races like say Mictlan, then I do not think it would bother me so much.