I'll admit I laughed at Calchet's posts here and I commend Swan for taking the critiques in good humor. (Which is better than what I can say for myself if it were to happen to me, hehe) The author did post to say it's really just a SP guide. For SP victories, you really don't need a whole lot. =) Maybe post a research path etc to spice it up a bit.
Its not a state of the art guide for sure but I appreciate the effort and it does have some not too bad substance (though I disagree with some of the suggestions from MP prespective).
Anyway there was this thread about MA marignon in which I posted some ideas that worked for me.